Comments: In May of 2005, I pulled off the biggest card purchase of my life up to that point. The REA auction closed and I won two cards - this Keefe and a 1887 N172 Old Judge Hoss Radbourne SGC 60. After the auction closed I called and requested signature receipt. I received a tracking number and nervously waited for the cards to arrive. In complete excitement, I waited and waited for the package to arrive and check the Track & Confirm website hourly. Eventually my anticipation was rewarded when the tracking number kicked back "Delivered". How? I wasn't home and the package required a signature. Would you believe the cards were shipped in a FedEx box overnight and left between the screen and front door by a FedEx courier? I was at work and unable to accept the box. This was an emergency. I jumped in the car and drove home to the front door. I was very lucky nobody took off with it. The package was there - in between the screen door and regular door - for all to see, and all to steal. Luckily nobody took the chance.

I don't think there's a card in my collection that has better color. This one screams 19th century in every way and the condition is just spectacular. I love this one and considerate it a favorite. Bright and clean, with flawless colors and perfect registration. Just a hint of corner wear. This is a classic nineteenth-century baseball card of one of the era's greatest stars, and an outstanding example.

UPDATE: In September, 2016 a PSA 8 showed up on eBay and sold: